Evaluation Criteria

EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH

Each item is scored out of 5 points
1Is the title appropriate for describing the study? (It should be short and concise, reflect the content of the study and be suitable for describing and generalizing it)
2Originality of the topic of the study
3Importance and rationale of the study
4Relevance of the study to aviation, space and psychology
5Clear statement of the aim of the study
6Setting, time and type of the study
7Population, sample size and sampling method of the study
8Inclusion or exclusion criteria
9Data collection method of the study
10(Dependent and independent) variables of the study
11Statement of the statistical methods used in the study
12Consistency of the results section with the aims of the study
13Clear and unbiased presentation of the results
14Appropriateness of the statistical analyses in the results
15Presentation of the statistical analysis results
16Statement of the main conclusions of the study
17Has the study produced important/useful conclusions?
18Are recommendations based on the results of the study made?
19Are the references sufficient in number, up to date, relevant and appropriately chosen? (Considered for full-text papers)
20Is the study written clearly?
Scientific language should be used correctly, the text should not be too long, and there should be no errors in grammar or abbreviations