Evaluation Criteria
EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH
| Each item is scored out of 5 points | |
|---|---|
| 1 | Is the title appropriate for describing the study? (It should be short and concise, reflect the content of the study and be suitable for describing and generalizing it) |
| 2 | Originality of the topic of the study |
| 3 | Importance and rationale of the study |
| 4 | Relevance of the study to aviation, space and psychology |
| 5 | Clear statement of the aim of the study |
| 6 | Setting, time and type of the study |
| 7 | Population, sample size and sampling method of the study |
| 8 | Inclusion or exclusion criteria |
| 9 | Data collection method of the study |
| 10 | (Dependent and independent) variables of the study |
| 11 | Statement of the statistical methods used in the study |
| 12 | Consistency of the results section with the aims of the study |
| 13 | Clear and unbiased presentation of the results |
| 14 | Appropriateness of the statistical analyses in the results |
| 15 | Presentation of the statistical analysis results |
| 16 | Statement of the main conclusions of the study |
| 17 | Has the study produced important/useful conclusions? |
| 18 | Are recommendations based on the results of the study made? |
| 19 | Are the references sufficient in number, up to date, relevant and appropriately chosen? (Considered for full-text papers) |
| 20 | Is the study written clearly? Scientific language should be used correctly, the text should not be too long, and there should be no errors in grammar or abbreviations |